Followers on this explicit Reddit thread did not embrace Billie Lourd’s function as aerobics fanatic Montana Duke within the ninth season of “American Horror Story,” subtitled “1984.” Redditor u/costelloethere stated, “Billie’s performing, notably in ‘1984,’ is fairly unhealthy. That monologue she delivers to Trevor close to the top was laughable, and never within the tacky, 80’s kinda approach.”
One other consumer, u/Addieprettygirl, pointed to the monologue as nicely, calling it “abysmal.” They added that whereas they acknowledged the campy nature of ’80s teen slashers, “there have been components of ‘1984’ that appeared like a horrible college play.”
Followers additionally identified that Lourd’s efficiency did not match the campy tone of the season. The OP responded to at least one consumer, saying, “She’s very monotone and it kinda labored in ‘Cult’ however not ‘1984.’” Others agreed that the gothic Winter Anderson from “American Horror Story: Cult” benefited from Lourd’s deadpan supply, however that very same performing model wasn’t proper for a very tubular camp counselor.
Regardless of the criticism and the recent takes, most customers weren’t too harsh on the thread. With 44 upvotes, u/BhangraFool stated, “I really like that you just requested this and I really like studying all of the replies as a result of even the stuff I disagree with, I am loving being right here surrounded by different followers who simply love this sequence a lot!”